Month: January 2009

  • Ep. 02 – The Lie

    How do you continue after such a mind-boggling premiere? You change the picture in typical LOST-style, and instead of delivering an episode that is mystery-focused, you go back to the very core of the show: the characters.

    The Episode…

    In line with last Season, this season also kicks off with a Hurley-centered episode (I kind of see Because You Left as a prologue, a short setting of the framework in which this chapter of the story will enroll). It seems Hurley is considered a great character for making bridges between seasons (bridges which at times can be confusing), which doesn’t really seem so unlikely. Anyway: I love it when they dig into Hurley. Jorge Garcia just seems to keep on adding layers to what essentially started as an uninteresting
    at character in the background. Kudos!

    Ben did some remarkable things again – it’s interesting to see his off-island in
    uences. We saw him take a package out of an air vent, show up at a butcher’s (brilliantly shown and cut, in my opinion) and – perhaps most breath-taking of all – in a church, in front of Ms. Hawking. Nice to see her again, even if the actress doesn’t really convince me. Is she Daniel Faraday’s mother? I’m willing to bet she is… And what was she doing in that basement? Looking for the island, perhaps? I also love the fact that a new confrontation between Ms. Hawking and Desmond is only a matter of time. Say what you will: the writers really know how to get the most out of their characters (unless they kill them off).

    The Lie marked the end of Frogurt. Haven’t seen a redshirt go out with such a bang since Arzt back in season 1. Nice exit Neil! Who were the people who shot Team Island? Are they the same people that tried to cut off Juliet’s arm? They wore jumpsuits – people said they were Dharma but I’m not buying it. Where’s the Dharma logo, for instance? I thought they were Danielle’s crew, but they sound a wee bit too English for that. Although… no one said the crew was French – we just knew Rousseau herself was. Although Montand isn’t exactly a British name.

    The Questions…

    Will I be right after all? Will the answer to question 7 (Rousseau’s expedition) be answered soon? Are these her crewmates? About question 9 (Charles versus Ben): we now know that Ben’s allied with a lot of people – what I suspected to be a personal feud between two powerful people (analogous to the game of chess between Charles Xavier and Magneto in X-Men) might just turn out to be a hidden war between two much larger forces…

    In All…

    I loved this episode. It was full of this sad yet funny awkwardness that is Hurley – but, just like in The Beginning of the End (season 4’s Hurley episode) the drama overweighed the fun (see the quote below if you don’t understand what I mean). It had some nice plot twists (Ana Lucia’s “Don’t get arrested” got an entirely different meaning at the end of the episode – could the ghosts be siding with Ben then?) and a great set-up for next week’s episode (Jones’ crew).

    Favourite Quote:
    Hurley: Okay. See, we did crash, but it was on this crazy island. And we waited for rescue, and there wasn’t any rescue. And there was a smoke monster, and then there were other people on the island. We called them the Others, and they started attacking us. And we found some hatches, and there was a button you had to push every 108 minutes or… well, I was never really clear on that. But… the Others didn’t have anything to do with the hatches. That was the DHARMA Initiative. The Others killed them, and now they’re trying to kill us. And then we teamed up with the Others because some worse people were coming on a freighter. Desmond’s girlfriend’s father sent them to kill us. So we stole their helicopter and we
    flew it to their freighter, but it blew up. And we couldn’t go back to the island because it disappeared, so then we crashed into the ocean, and we
    floated there for a while until a boat came and picked us up. And by then, there were six of us. That part was true. (Whispers) But the re… But the rest of the people… who were on the plane? They’re still on that island.

  • Ep. 01 – Because You Left

    With the words “It’s good to be back” branded in its forehead, LOST emerged back on our screens. And with reason: not only was the fourth season absolutely stellar, it also got rewarded with a bonus: an extra episode this season, resulting in a double-feature premiere. And what kind of a premiere! Let’s start at the beginning – the first hour: Because You Left.

    The Episode…

    The cat’s out of the bag. For anyone still wondering what Season Five – and with that, what seems like the very core of LOST’s insanely complex story – is about, the answer is given in the first five minutes of this very episode: killing Hitler – I mean time travel. All of a sudden, and in typical LOST-fashion, the scope of the series widened again: Season 1 was about surviving, Season 2 showed us the Dharma initiative, Season 3 went beyond that and introduced us to the Others and Season 4 finally showed us what happened beyond the island. With every step, more things started making sense. The presence of the hatch – something completely and utterly insane in season 1 – became intelligible when Dharma was introduced in Season 2.

    Now, we essentially have the same thing: a lot of things start making more sense. The presence of Adam and Eve back in Season 1? Ben knowing all? Richard not aging? Doesn’t seem so far-fetched anymore from where I’m standing.

    So the island is unstuck in time. Or is it? For Richard, it seemed as if John Locke disappeared (as opposed to the other way around). So what is really happening? I personally do think the island is skipping and not the people on it – but why does someone like Richard not skip, while our Losties do? Is his bond with the island too strong? Does he have a Constant (maybe Jacob)? The question towards Richard becomes increasingly interesting as the question towards Ben slowly gets unraveled.

    I’m really enjoying the course the story-telling in Season 5 seems to take: there’s no more flashbacks, no more flashforwards – but the whole thing does flash. It still feels like LOST, but it’s an entirely different approach (even if it is the most obvious choice at this point in the story). I do hope that the entire season won’t be as hectic as this first episode, though. There was a lot of flashing going on, but it lacked the archimedical point that LOST episodes usually have (which normally revolve around the now non-existant
    flash-character).

    The Questions…

    Nice answer to the second question: the island hasn’t just gone back in time, it’s skipping in time. It’s going all over the place. Nice idea: it will allow the writers to make sense of a lot of past stuff (like they did in the prologue by telling us what the Arrow station was for). Other than that, none of the questions got tackled – but one question completely solved isn’t so bad either.

    In All…

    If you think Season 4 was insane, you will soon see that Season 5 decides to kick things up a notch in the bizzare department. In absolute essence, though, even Season 5 is still about the characters. And they are what made this episode believable: on the one hand, there is someone as sofisticated and confused as Daniel Faraday explaining whatever happened to the island (“we can never make another street”), and on the other there is someone like Sawyer, who just wants a damn shirt. It works. Jack might have shaven off that horrible beard (may it rest in peace) but he still acts like bearded Jack: mildly confused, tired – not at all hero-like. Sayid might have stopped working for Ben, but he is at the darkest point in his journey. The characters work: obviously all Bernard cares about is pleasing his down-to-earth Rose, even if the island is going bananas. Everyone has evolved, but no one truly has changed.

    Heroes, you should be writing that down. It’s important.

    Favourite Quote:
    Sawyer: “Open up! It’s the ghost of Christmas future!”.

  • The Chronicles of Narnia (C.S. Lewis)

    Let me tell you this straight: I had the greatest mood swings reading The Chronicles of Narnia (all seven books). At times it was unbelievably corny, at other times it was eery (but not on purpose, I think) and there were rare times were I was truly interested and curious as to how it would unfold. So how do I review this?

    First off: it’s very apparent – more so than in the movies – that The chronicles of Narnia is actually a religious work in desguise. And that’s okay, I have got nothing against that: I think one of the great
    strenghts of religion is the fact that everyone can be united even if there points of view aren’t exactly the same. But in the end, the view C.S. Lewis shows us in The Chronicles of Narnia is scary to say the least – if not borderlining religious terrorism.

    What do you learn from reading these books? That there is a God – Aslan – that creates and destroys. That all things come to an end. Now this is okay. The question is how and why exactly things seem to end. In Narnia’s case, the end of the world comes with its secularisation. Its enlightenment. And that is a scary thought. Do you really want to feed this thought to children – that critical thinking about religion might have desastrous consequences?

    My conclusion in all this is the following: there’s books you can read that never age. The Lord of the Rings is such a book: it’s over fifty years old but it still works. Books by Roald Dahl do this too – and they’re almost just as moralizing as Narnia. But The Chronicles of Narnia describes the glory of an era where people still feared God and lived in constant angst of pissing him off.

    That means you can only read it as an ancient text – like people who read Jane Austen: it’s a story that doesn’t apply well to the current society. The difference between Lewis and someone like Austen is, however, that Lewis is not a good writer – not even close. His work is chaotic, poorly written and way too stereotypical. If an author says something is indescribable every other page (a trend that seems to get worse towards the end), then you just know he’s not the brightest page in the book.

    So why people see C.S. Lewis as one of the greatest authors of the 20th Century, I will never understand. And how deeply religious people don’t get offended by reading this, I don’t get either. I guess that’s just how the world works?

  • Tintenherz

    (Little disclaimer before we start: I usually always call movies by their original names – in this case it would be Inkheart. But seeing how Inkheart is based on a German book and I just can’t shake the book’s original name off me, I am going to call the movie like the book: Tintenherz.)

    Messes and where they come from

    It’s a movie about a book, based on a book, with characters from books. Not an easy task! Tintenherz could have been a revolution in movie making. Why? We have a very successful (at least in the US and Germany) author, Cornelia Funke, who promised fans she’d be keeping guard over her story and even signing up as producer of the movie. She cast Brendan Fraser herself, kept a close look on the scriptwriters… Nothing could go wrong.

    But they did. This movie is a horrible mess. More than that: it is a horrible mess in the typical places where book-to-movie adaptions tend to be messes, but this mess is so inexplicable and so random that I for the life of me can’t seem to understand who made said mess and where it came from. Like having two cats, and one of them takes a dump on your carpet. It boggles the mind.

    Where does this movie go wrong? Strangely enough – with a mediocre actor like Fraser at the helm of the performance ship – not in its casting. Every actor does a great job. The typical book-to-movie give-ins do apply: Meggie is actually a lot younger than the person playing her, Mo has the voice but not the looks… But one is used to that. Special kudos to Paul Bettany for playing the role of Staubfinger (Dustfinger) and doing a great job at it. He is one creepy guy. No kudos to Andy Serkis, who plays Capricorn in such a manner that he’s so unscary it’s laughable. And, oddly enough, the introduction of Capricorn in the movie (after about half an hour) is the point where things start going terribly, terribly wrong.

    Now, I have to say I wasn’t the biggest fan of Capricorn while reading the book. He’s pretty dull, does little to nothing and isn’t really scary in my opinion. But he was never laughable – which is exactly what he is in the movie. Every other line is a joke – but not a good one. Now I realize this isn’t Serkis’ fault, but he performs the character in such a way that it becomes plain and boring at best.

    Up to the point where we first see Capricorn, the movie is pretty decent: it’s moody, mildly scary (just like the book) and we search together with Meggie for the truth about her mother’s disappearance. But once we travel to Capricorn’s village, the movie repeatedly starts straying from the book. Why? There is only one possible explanation: every change has something to do with closing plotlines that were left open at the end of Tintenherz. Tintenherz is a trilogy – but Inkheart will probably never see a sequel. They made sure of that, and not just by means of making a poor movie.

    In all…

    I was honestly pissed off when I exited the movie theatre after seeing Tintenherz. This movie had just about everything it needed to be: a nice plot, source material that can be ported straight to the screen (it’s short and very little happens but it’s still exciting), good actors and a capable producer. But it wasn’t meant to be. And that pissed me off: bad movies are made all the time because incapable people get loads of money, but when capable people screw up like this… that pisses me off.

    So Tintenherz: thank you for making me angry!